Mon–Fri 7am–7pm · Sat 7am–1pm

Signs Your Hot Water System Is Failing (and What to Do About It)

Most people only think about their hot water system when it stops working. That is usually the worst time to be making decisions: it is early in the morning, the kids are waiting to get in the shower, and you are standing in a cold bathroom wondering whether this is a quick fix or a new unit.

Plumber fitting an electric hot water heater
  • Licensed & InsuredPL 6567 · GF 9850
  • Same-Day ServiceSame-day repairs available
  • Free QuotesUpfront fixed pricing
  • Based in DianellaServicing the Perth metro area

The good news is that hot water systems rarely fail without warning. Almost every unit gives you hints first. They are easy to miss if you do not know what to look for, but once you do, you can usually book a repair or a planned replacement on your terms instead of in a panic.

This guide walks through the common signs that a hot water system is struggling, what each one tends to mean, what you can safely check yourself, and when it is time to call a licensed plumber. It applies to gas storage, gas instant, electric storage, electric instant and heat pump systems, with notes where the type matters.

Why it matters

Water Corporation lists hot water systems among the common sources of household leaks in Perth homes, alongside taps, toilets, air conditioners and garden reticulation. Gas faults are a safety issue too, so never put them off.

Sign 1: The water is not getting as hot as it used to

This is the most common complaint we hear. The water is warm but not hot, or it starts hot and fades quickly, or you find yourself turning the mixer further toward hot than you used to.

What it can mean depends on the type of system:

  • Electric storage: a failing heating element, a faulty thermostat, or a tripped safety switch. Elements wear out and thermostats drift over time.
  • Gas storage: a pilot or ignition problem, a dirty burner, a faulty thermostat, or a build-up of sediment in the tank that stops heat getting through to the water.
  • Gas instant: a scaled-up heat exchanger, a low flow of water through the unit, or a fault in the control board or sensors.
  • Heat pump: reduced airflow around the unit, a fault in the compressor or controls, or a system that is relying too heavily on its backup element.

If you are only getting lukewarm water from one tap but not others, the problem may not be the heater at all. A worn mixer cartridge, a blocked tap filter or a faulty non-return valve can all mimic a failing system. If the problem is across the whole house, look at the heater first.

Sign 2: You run out of hot water faster than before

With a storage system, running out sooner than you used to is a classic symptom of sediment build-up or a failing element. Sediment settles at the bottom of the tank and reduces the amount of water the unit can actually heat. It can also make the tank noisy and less efficient.

Before you assume the system is failing, ask whether anything in your household has changed. A new baby, a teenager who has discovered long showers, a new dishwasher or a new family member staying all put more demand on a system that was sized for something different. If your needs have grown, the unit may be working perfectly and simply be too small. We cover this in our guide to choosing the right size system.

If nothing has changed and the water is running out faster, it is worth having it looked at.

Sign 3: Rusty, brown or smelly hot water

Cold water that runs clear while hot water comes out discoloured is a strong hint that the problem is inside your hot water system rather than in the mains. Rust-coloured water can mean internal corrosion in the tank. A metallic taste or a smell can mean the same thing, or can mean bacterial growth in a unit that has been sitting on a low setting.

Two quick checks you can do safely:

  1. Run the cold tap at the kitchen sink and see whether it is clear.
  2. Run the hot tap and compare it in a clean glass.

If only the hot water is discoloured, do not ignore it. Corrosion is a sign that the tank, or a component inside it, is nearing the end of its life. A repair may not be possible for a corroded tank, and we would rather tell you that straight away so you can plan a replacement.

Sign 4: Noises you have not heard before

Hot water systems are not silent, but they should not be loud. Things to listen for:

  • Banging, popping or rumbling from a storage tank. Often caused by sediment trapped under the element or burner, where water boils underneath it and bursts through.
  • A high-pitched whine or whistle. Can point to scale in a gas instant unit or a partly blocked pipe or valve.
  • Clicking that does not stop. In a gas system this can mean the ignition is trying and failing to light.
  • Humming or buzzing. In an electric or heat pump system this can be an electrical component that is struggling.

Noise on its own is not an emergency, but it is the system telling you something. A new noise is worth a look.

Sign 5: Water around the base of the unit

A puddle, a damp patch or a stain on the ground under or around your hot water system should always be investigated. It does not always mean the tank has failed. Water can come from:

  • The temperature and pressure relief valve. Some dripping or discharge from the relief valve line can be normal when the system is heating. A constant flow or a heavy discharge is not.
  • A loose or worn fitting on the inlet or outlet pipes, which is often a straightforward repair.
  • A leak from the tank itself, which is not repairable. A tank that is leaking through its body has reached the end of its life.

If water is coming from the tank, turn off the power or gas to the unit and shut off the cold water supply to it, then call a licensed plumber. Do not leave it running, because a slow leak at the base of a unit can cause damage to flooring, fences and foundations, and wastes water the whole time.

Because water leaks can be hidden, it is worth knowing how to check for one across the whole property. Water Corporation's test is to turn off all taps indoors and outdoors, note the last three digits on your water meter, wait 15 minutes, and then check whether those digits have changed. If they have moved, water is going somewhere, and the hot water system and its pipework are one of the places to look.

Sign 6: The pilot light or burner is behaving oddly (gas systems)

If you have a gas hot water system, pay attention to the flame and the way the unit lights. Building and Energy points to flame discolouration and difficulty relighting as warning signs for gas appliances in general. The same logic applies to a gas water heater: a flame that should be steady and blue but looks yellow, orange or unsteady, or a unit that keeps going out, needs to be looked at.

In Western Australia, gasfitting work must be carried out by a person who holds the appropriate gasfitting licence or permit from Building and Energy. That includes repairs to the gas side of a hot water system. gas fitting

Sign 7: The system is simply old

Every hot water system has a working life, and the right answer depends on the model, the water quality, how it has been maintained and how hard it has been run. We are not going to put a number of years on it, because it varies too much from unit to unit. What we can say is that if your system is well into its working life and you are seeing more than one of the signs above, repeated repairs often stop making sense.

What you can safely check yourself

Before you call anyone, a few checks can save you a visit:

  • Check the power. For electric and heat pump systems, look at the switchboard for a tripped safety switch or circuit breaker. Reset it once. If it trips again, leave it and call us. Do not work on electrical parts yourself.
  • Check the gas. For gas systems, make sure the gas supply to the unit is turned on and that other gas appliances in the house are working. If they are not, the problem is the supply rather than the heater.
  • Check the taps. Make sure the problem is not limited to a single tap or a single bathroom.
  • Look for water. Check around the base of the unit and under the relief valve line.

What not to do: do not remove covers, do not touch wiring, and do not try to drain or flush the tank without knowing how. Water supply and sanitary plumbing work must be done by a licensed plumber, apart from some limited homeowner tasks.

Repair or replace: how we help you decide

We will not push you into a new system if a repair will do the job, and we will not patch a unit that is clearly finished. When we visit, we look at:

We look at what is actually wrong, how the unit is installed, and whether the system still suits your household. If you are weighing up gas, electric or heat pump, see our pages on gas hot water systems and heat pump hot water systems.

If you do replace a system, remember that the licensed contractor should lodge a notice of intention before major work (except for emergency work) and a certificate of compliance within five working days of finishing. Building and Energy describes the certificate as a six-year guarantee of compliance, and owners should ask for their copy. For gas appliances, a gasfitter should also give you a Notice of Completion for work other than servicing, and fix a compliance badge to the installation.

A note on water temperature

You might think the simple fix for lukewarm water is to turn the thermostat up. Do not do this without advice. In Western Australia there are rules about when a maximum delivery temperature must be provided at personal-hygiene outlets such as showers and basins, set out in Building and Energy's Industry Bulletin 161. We can tell you what applies to your home and make sure your system is set up correctly, rather than leaving it to guesswork.

When to call us straight away

Call a licensed plumber promptly if water is pooling around the base of the tank, you smell gas, the safety switch keeps tripping, or the relief valve is discharging heavily. If you are not sure whether what you are seeing is serious, ring and describe it.

Talk to Pacer Plumbing & Gas

If your hot water system is showing any of these signs, call us on 0413 496 949 or book a time online. You can also send us a message with a photo of the unit and its label, and we will point you in the right direction. We will tell you plainly whether you need a repair, a replacement or nothing at all.

For more on what we do, see our page on hot water systems repairs and installations.

FAQ

How do I know if my hot water system needs repair or replacement?

If the fault is a single component such as an element, thermostat or valve and the rest of the unit is sound, repair is usually sensible. If the tank itself is leaking or corroded, or the system has had several faults close together, replacement is usually the better choice. A licensed plumber can inspect the unit and tell you which applies.

Why is my hot water lukewarm instead of hot?

Common causes include a failing element or thermostat in an electric system, ignition or burner problems in a gas system, scale in an instant unit, or sediment in a storage tank. It can also be a tap or mixer fault if only one outlet is affected.

Is it normal for the relief valve to drip?

Some discharge from the relief valve can be normal while the system is heating, but a constant or heavy flow is not. If water is running from the relief valve line all the time, have a licensed plumber check the system.

Can I fix my hot water system myself?

You can check the safety switch, the gas supply and the taps, and look for water or fault codes. Water supply plumbing and gasfitting work must be carried out by suitably licensed people in Western Australia, so repairs beyond those basic checks should be left to a licensed plumber or gas fitter.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Still unsure? Call us on 0413 496 949 and we’ll talk it through.

If the fault is a single component such as an element, thermostat or valve and the rest of the unit is sound, repair is usually sensible. If the tank itself is leaking or corroded, or the system has had several faults close together, replacement is usually the better choice. A licensed plumber can inspect the unit and tell you which applies.

Common causes include a failing element or thermostat in an electric system, ignition or burner problems in a gas system, scale in an instant unit, or sediment in a storage tank. It can also be a tap or mixer fault if only one outlet is affected.

Some discharge from the relief valve can be normal while the system is heating, but a constant or heavy flow is not. If water is running from the relief valve line all the time, have a licensed plumber check the system.

You can check the safety switch, the gas supply and the taps, and look for water or fault codes. Water supply plumbing and gasfitting work must be carried out by suitably licensed people in Western Australia, so repairs beyond those basic checks should be left to a licensed plumber or gas fitter.
Call 0413 496 949 Book